Surgery in Türkiye – can I sue in a UK court?
When a UK court can hear a claim about surgery in Türkiye, why Turkish law may still apply, and what it takes to enforce an English judgment in Türkiye.
Something went wrong after your operation in Türkiye, and going to court abroad feels overwhelming. Can you simply sue here, in a UK court?
Sometimes you can – but winning in a UK court is only half the story. This guide looks at one narrow question: when a UK court can hear your claim, and what you can actually do with the judgment. How a claim works in Türkiye itself – mediation, the consumer court, experts, power of attorney – is covered in our guide Suing a Turkish clinic from the UK, which we do not repeat here.
This is general information focused on England and Wales (Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own procedures), not legal advice. A lawyer in the UK and one in Türkiye should assess your case together.
Who exactly can I sue in the UK?
The answer depends first on who you contracted with and who you paid, not on where the operation happened. There are usually three possible defendants:
| Defendant | Typical basis | UK court? |
|---|---|---|
| A UK-based agent, facilitator or package organiser | Its own contract with you, its own promises and mistakes | Usually yes – it is based here |
| The Turkish clinic or hospital | Contract and/or negligence | Only in limited situations (see below) |
| The individual surgeon in Türkiye | Negligence | Harder still – often no contract with you and no UK link |
A company with a UK address on the contract is a very different defendant from a clinic in Antalya you paid by bank transfer.
Can I sue the UK agent or facilitator at home?
Usually yes, and this is often the most realistic home route: a company based in England or Wales can normally be sued here without special permission.
The catch is what it is liable for. A UK facilitator is generally responsible for its own obligations: the services it promised, the information it gave you about the clinic or surgeon, and how it handled the booking. Whether it is also liable for the surgery depends on what it sold you and in whose name – for example, whether it presented the whole package, including treatment, as its own product. Our guide to agencies and facilitators explains this in more detail.
Tip: Screenshot the agent’s website and adverts now, as they looked when you booked. Promises such as “we vet every surgeon” can matter later – and websites change.
Can I sue the Turkish clinic in an English court?
Possibly, through one of two doors. Neither opens automatically, and the clinic can challenge the court’s jurisdiction.
1. The consumer route. Since the end of the Brexit transition period, sections 15A to 15E of the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982 contain consumer rules. Under section 15B, a consumer domiciled in the UK can sue the other party in the courts for the place where the consumer is domiciled, whatever the other party’s domicile – provided the contract is a consumer contract within the section. In broad terms, that means the business pursued its activities in the UK or directed them there, and your contract falls within those activities. Where this applies, the claim form can generally be served abroad without first asking the court’s permission (CPR 6.33).
For a clinic, the key question is whether it directed its activities to the UK. Factors that may be relevant include:
- ads and testimonials aimed at UK patients;
- prices quoted in pounds, UK phone or WhatsApp numbers;
- consultations or “open days” held in the UK;
- UK-based representatives.
How this applies to a clinic abroad is not settled – treat it as an argument, not a guarantee.
2. Service out with the court’s permission. If the consumer rules do not apply, you need the court’s permission to serve the claim on the clinic in Türkiye (CPR 6.36 and Practice Direction 6B). In outline you must show a serious issue to be tried, that the claim fits one of the listed “gateways”, and that England is the proper place for the case.
The best-known gateway for injury claims is the tort gateway: damage sustained within the jurisdiction. In FS Cairo (Nile Plaza) LLC v Brownlie [2021] UKSC 45 – a road accident in Egypt – the Supreme Court held that “damage” means actionable harm, direct or indirect, caused by the wrongful act, so harm suffered in England after an accident abroad can count. Ongoing pain, treatment and lost earnings in the UK may therefore pass the gateway – but England must also be the appropriate forum.
Why might the court still send the case to Türkiye?
Because the clinic can argue that Türkiye is clearly the more appropriate place for the trial. The court weighs where evidence and witnesses are, which law applies, the language of the records and where a judgment would be enforced.
In a surgical claim, many factors point to Türkiye: the operating team, records in Turkish, Turkish law and the clinic’s assets. Your UK doctors, continuing harm and the clinic’s UK marketing point the other way. Expect this to be fought early – and to cost money before the medical questions are reached.
Which law would a UK court apply?
Possibly Turkish law – even in a court in London.
- Negligence (tort): under the retained Rome II rules, the starting point is the law of the country where the damage occurs. Where the injury happened during surgery in Türkiye, that will often be Turkish law, subject to exceptions for a manifestly closer connection elsewhere.
- Contract: the retained Rome I consumer rule (Article 6) can point to the law of the consumer’s home country where the business directed its activities there. But Article 6(4)(a) excludes contracts for services supplied to the consumer exclusively in another country. Surgery carried out entirely in Türkiye is likely to fall within that exclusion, so unless your contract chose English law, the general rules may again lead to Turkish law.
Foreign law needs expert evidence, which adds cost, and time limits can follow it too – do not assume the UK three-year personal injury limit is the one that counts.
I won in England – can I enforce the judgment in Türkiye?
Only after a Turkish court has granted enforcement (tenfiz). If the clinic has no money or property in the UK, an English judgment does not by itself let you collect anything in Türkiye.
Under Turkish private international law (Act No. 5718), a Turkish court checks conditions including:
| Condition | What it means in practice |
|---|---|
| Reciprocity | Turkish commentary refers to Court of Cassation decisions accepting de facto reciprocity with the UK, as there is no bilateral enforcement treaty – this should be checked for current practice |
| No exclusive Turkish jurisdiction | The subject matter must not belong exclusively to Turkish courts |
| Public policy | The result must not clearly conflict with Turkish public order |
| Right to be heard | The clinic must have been properly summoned and able to defend itself |
The last point catches many claimants out. Türkiye is a party to the Hague Service Convention but has objected to service by post, and Turkish courts have refused to enforce foreign judgments served by ordinary post or courier. The claim form should go through the official channel – this takes time and needs Turkish translations.
In practice, enforcement means a second set of proceedings, a Turkish lawyer, translations and more time.
So is suing at home worth it?
It depends on who the defendant is and where its money is. A claim against a solvent UK company can make good sense; one against a Turkish clinic may be worthwhile if it has UK assets or as settlement leverage. Otherwise you may run two sets of proceedings where one in Türkiye – or a settlement – would have been quicker.
| Route | When possible | Advantage | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| UK claim against UK agent | You contracted with a UK company | Home court, English law likely, easy enforcement | Agent liable only for its own role |
| UK claim against Turkish clinic (consumer rules) | Clinic directed activities to the UK | No permission needed to serve | Jurisdiction challenge; Turkish law may apply; enforcement in Türkiye |
| UK claim with permission to serve out | A gateway, e.g. harm sustained in England | Can work without a UK contract partner | Forum challenge, cost, delay, enforcement |
| Claim in Türkiye | Almost always | Court where clinic and assets are | Distance, language, different procedure |
| Section 75 / chargeback | Card payment meeting the conditions | Claim against a UK card provider | Conditions and payment chain must fit |
| Settlement or mediation | Any time | Fastest, cheapest | You must accept a compromise |
What about my credit card?
If you paid at least part of the price by credit card, Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act may let you claim against the card provider for the supplier’s breach of contract or misrepresentation. The cash price must be over £100 and not more than £30,000, and the House of Lords confirmed in 2007 that Section 75 is not limited to UK transactions. Payment through an agent or intermediary rather than to the supplier directly can break the required link. For debit cards, ask your bank about a chargeback. If the provider refuses, you can go to the Financial Ombudsman Service. More detail is in getting money back from a Turkish clinic.
What should I collect before seeing a lawyer?
- Every contract, quote and booking confirmation – note which company issued each one and its address
- Invoices and proof of payment, showing who received the money and how you paid
- Screenshots of the clinic’s and agent’s marketing aimed at you: UK ads, pound prices, UK numbers, UK consultations
- Messages with the clinic and agent, exported with dates
- Medical records from Türkiye, including the consent form
- Letters and reports from UK doctors, and receipts for treatment and travel here
- A timeline, including the date you first realised something was wrong
- Any information on the clinic’s UK presence or assets
Tip: Ask the UK solicitor and the Turkish lawyer to speak to each other early. The choice of court, the applicable law and enforceability are linked – deciding one without the others can waste a year.
Read more
Frequently asked questions
Can I sue a Turkish clinic in a UK court at all?
Sometimes. UK consumer jurisdiction rules can allow a UK-domiciled consumer to sue at home where the business directed its activities to the UK. Otherwise the court's permission to serve outside the UK is needed. Neither route is automatic, and the clinic can challenge jurisdiction.
Is it easier to sue the UK agency I booked through?
Usually, yes, because it is based here. But it is liable for its own contractual promises and mistakes, not automatically for every surgical error by the clinic. What it promised and in whose name it sold the package matter a great deal.
What counts as a clinic directing its activities to the UK?
There is no single test. English-language marketing aimed at UK patients, UK phone numbers, prices in pounds, UK consultation days or UK-targeted advertising can all be relevant. A court looks at the overall picture.
Will a UK court apply UK law?
Not necessarily. For injuries suffered during treatment in Türkiye, Turkish law will often apply to a claim in tort. For the contract, the consumer protection rule pointing to UK law generally does not apply to services provided entirely abroad, unless the contract chose UK law.
Can I enforce an English judgment in Türkiye?
It is possible but requires separate enforcement proceedings in a Turkish court. The court checks conditions such as reciprocity, public policy, exclusive Turkish jurisdiction and whether the clinic was properly served and heard.
Can I just email or post the claim form to the clinic?
That is risky. Türkiye generally requires service through official channels under the Hague Service Convention, and Turkish courts have refused to enforce foreign judgments served by ordinary post.
Could my credit card company pay instead?
If you paid at least part of the price by credit card directly to the supplier and the price was over £100 and up to £30,000, a Section 75 claim may be possible, including for treatment abroad. Debit card payments may be disputed through chargeback.
Do I need a lawyer in the UK or in Türkiye?
Ideally both. A UK solicitor can assess jurisdiction and UK routes; a lawyer admitted in Türkiye can assess Turkish law, time limits and whether an English judgment could be enforced there.
Legal questions after treatment in Türkiye?
The legal content on this website is written by Av. Yakup Oral Kulaksız, a lawyer admitted in Türkiye (Ankara Bar Association). If you have questions about your rights after treatment in Türkiye – for example about malpractice, a deposit or a contract – you can contact him directly.
Note: Av. Kulaksız is also active in the health tourism sector himself. Contacting him does not create a lawyer–client relationship. Only send medical documents if you wish to. In a medical emergency, call 999 (UK) or 112.
Sources
- legislation.gov.uk: Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982, section 15A
- legislation.gov.uk: Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982, section 15B (consumer contracts)
- legislation.gov.uk: Civil Procedure Rules, rule 6.33
- UK Supreme Court: Press summary, FS Cairo (Nile Plaza) LLC v Brownlie [2021] UKSC 45
- IPPT: Rome I Regulation, Article 6 (consumer contracts)
- Mondaq: Recognition and enforcement of UK judgments in Turkey (2013)
- Mondaq: Enforcement of foreign court judgments in Türkiye – the impact of service method (2025)
- Which?: Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act
- 1 Crown Office Row: Medical treatment claims under section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 (2021)
Your comments
Do you have a question about this topic or want to share your experience? Write it here. Comments appear after a short review.
No comments yet. Be the first to write one.