Patient rights & malpractice

Leaving a negative review of a Turkish clinic: what you can say and what to do if they threaten you

Opinion or false fact, photos, names, screenshots, legal threats, offers to delete for money: what UK patients should know before reviewing a Turkish clinic.

Your treatment in Türkiye did not go as promised and you want to warn other patients. That is legitimate. But some patients then receive a message: delete the review or we will report you, or sue. This guide explains what you can safely write, where the legal limits are in Türkiye and the UK, and how to react to threats or offers. It is general information, not legal advice on your case.

Can I leave a negative review of a clinic?

Yes. You are entitled to describe your own experience and give your honest opinion, even if it is harsh. Both Turkish and English law protect criticism – what they do not protect is untrue statements of fact, insults and the misuse of other people’s private data.

A clinic has no right to good reviews, but it has a right not to face false allegations, and its staff have a right to their honour and privacy.

Opinion or statement of fact – where is the line?

The key question is: could someone check whether your sentence is true? If so, it is a statement of fact, and you should be able to show it is true. If it is your assessment of something that happened, it is an opinion – and opinions get more leeway, provided you say what they are based on.

In England and Wales, the Defamation Act 2013 provides a defence of honest opinion: the statement must be an opinion, it must indicate – at least in general terms – what the opinion is based on, and an honest person could have held that opinion on the basis of facts that existed at the time. Truth is a separate defence. Turkish courts also distinguish between permitted criticism and insults or false allegations.

Fine (usually) Risky
“My stitches opened on day five and I could not reach anyone at the clinic for three days.” (documented) “They left me to die.” (exaggerated, not a fact)
“In my opinion, aftercare was poor – I had two short video calls in six weeks.” “This clinic is a criminal gang.”
“I was quoted £3,500 and charged £4,200 on arrival. I have the messages.” “They rip off every patient.” (you cannot know this)
“I was not seen by the surgeon before the operation, only by a coordinator.” (if true) “The surgeon is not a real doctor.” (unless proven)
“I would not recommend this clinic.” Insults, swear words, comments on someone’s appearance or origin
“The result is uneven and I am now seeing a UK surgeon about it.” “They botched hundreds of operations.”

Three rules help: write in the first person (“I”, “my”), stick to what you experienced yourself, and separate facts from your conclusions. Words like “fraud”, “criminal” or “malpractice” are allegations of wrongdoing; if no court or authority has decided this, describe the facts instead and let readers draw their own conclusions.

Tip: Write the review a few days after the worst moment, not in the middle of it. Angry wording is the part clinics most often use against patients – the facts usually speak for themselves.

Can I post photos, doctors’ names or chat screenshots?

Partly – it depends on whose data it is.

  • Your own before/after photos: generally your decision – but you cannot control them once they are online.
  • The surgeon’s name: a factual mention of the doctor who treated you, linked to what happened, is usually less problematic. Avoid insulting or personal comments.
  • Other staff, coordinators, interpreters: avoid full names, personal photos, private phone numbers and social media profiles. Describing a role (“the coordinator”) is enough.
  • Chat screenshots: a screenshot showing a price promise or a confirmation can be useful evidence. Before posting, blank out phone numbers, names of other staff and anything that concerns other patients. Do not publish entire private conversations.
  • Other patients: never post their photos, names or stories without consent.

Google’s own policy prohibits personal information without consent, harassment and “unsubstantiated allegations” of criminal or unethical behaviour in reviews – so even content that is legally fine can be removed by the platform.

Keep complete, unedited copies of everything for yourself as evidence.

The clinic threatens to report me or sue – what does that mean?

It does not mean you have done anything wrong; many such messages are meant to put pressure on you. Take them seriously, but do not panic.

Criminal complaint in Türkiye. Insult is an offence under Art. 125 of the Turkish Penal Code; the basic penalty is three months’ to two years’ imprisonment or a judicial fine, increased if committed publicly. Under the Turkish rules on insult offences, an investigation generally starts only on the complaint of the person concerned, and the complaint must be filed within six months of learning of the act and who did it. For many insult cases, a reconciliation (uzlaştırma) or prepayment procedure applies before any trial; Law No. 7531 of November 2024 changed which cases fall under which procedure. A complaint first goes to a prosecutor, who decides whether there is a case at all. A factual, honest review is a weak basis for a prosecution – an insulting one is not.

Civil claims in Türkiye. Under Arts. 24–25 of the Turkish Civil Code, anyone whose personality rights are unlawfully attacked can ask a court to stop the attack and claim compensation. Removal of online content used to be requested from criminal judgeships of peace under Art. 9 of Law No. 5651. The Constitutional Court annulled that article, effective 10 October 2024, and according to a July 2026 report by the Turkish freedom-of-expression association İFÖD no replacement had been enacted; applicants now go to civil courts for preliminary injunctions, a route that appeal courts have sometimes overturned. The legal situation is therefore in flux – check its current state with a lawyer.

Can a Turkish case reach me in the UK? In principle, a complaint can be filed in Türkiye even if you live in the UK. In practice, the reach is limited:

  • Extradition generally requires that the conduct is also a crime in the UK. Criminal libel was abolished in England and Wales, so extradition over a review is very unlikely.
  • A Turkish civil judgment is not automatically enforceable in the UK; the clinic would have to take further steps here.
  • It can matter if you travel to Türkiye again – for example for a revision. Ask a Turkish lawyer to check for any proceedings before a return trip.

A claim in England and Wales. If you live in England or Wales, the clinic could in principle sue you there. Under section 1 of the Defamation Act 2013, a statement is only defamatory if it caused or is likely to cause serious harm to reputation; for a business trading for profit, that means serious financial loss. Truth and honest opinion are defences. Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own rules.

The clinic offers money or a free revision if I delete the review – what should I watch?

Such offers can be a reasonable solution – or a way to make you give up your rights cheaply.

  • Get everything in writing: what exactly you receive, when, and who pays for flights, hotel and aftercare.
  • Do not delete first: agree the order – payment or confirmed treatment date first, deletion afterwards, or both at the same time.
  • Read the waiver: many settlement texts say you waive “all claims”. If you might still need corrective surgery in the UK, that could cost you far more than the offer.
  • Watch confidentiality and “no further statements” clauses: they may bar you from talking about your experience at all, including to authorities.
  • Revision in the same clinic: think carefully whether you want to be treated again by the team you are complaining about. A second opinion from an independent surgeon helps.
  • Platform rules: Google’s policy prohibits businesses from offering incentives for the revision or removal of a negative review. You can report the offer to Google.

Never accept an offer under time pressure (“only valid today”). Have a lawyer read any agreement that includes a waiver.

Can the clinic get my Google review removed?

It can try in two ways. First, it can flag the review to Google, which removes content that breaks its policies – fake or conflict-of-interest reviews, harassment, personal information, unsubstantiated allegations of crime or off-topic content. Second, it can seek a court order and send a legal removal request.

An honest review of your own experience, written factually, generally does not break Google’s policy. If your review is removed, you can ask Google for the reason and, if appropriate, post a revised version without the problematic parts. Keep a copy of your original text with the date.

How do I write a fair, safe review?

Use this checklist before you press “post”:

  • I describe only what I experienced myself, in the first person.
  • Facts I state are true and I can prove them (messages, invoices, photos, medical letters).
  • Opinions are recognisable as opinions (“in my view”, “I was disappointed”) and I say what they are based on.
  • No insults, swear words or comments on appearance, origin or religion.
  • No allegations of crimes (“fraud”, “criminal”) that no authority has confirmed.
  • No private data of staff or other patients; screenshots are redacted.
  • Dates and amounts are correct; I do not exaggerate.
  • I mention what the clinic did right, if anything – this makes the review more credible.
  • I have kept copies of the review and all evidence.

What should I do if I am threatened?

Stay calm and stay factual. A measured reaction protects you better than a public argument.

  1. Document everything: screenshot threats with date, time and sender; save emails and voice messages.
  2. Do not escalate: no counter-insults, no new posts about the threat, no public “they are threatening me” updates in anger.
  3. Do not delete anything in a panic: first check, ideally with advice, whether any wording is actually problematic. Editing out a single exaggerated sentence can be more sensible than deleting everything.
  4. Answer briefly, or not at all: if you answer, say only that you stand by your account of your own experience and will review any specific concern.
  5. Get legal advice: a lawyer admitted in Türkiye for Turkish proceedings, and a UK solicitor if you receive a letter of claim in the UK.
  6. Report threats of violence: contact the police in the UK, and report harassment to the platform.

Tip: If you are planning a complaint or a compensation claim, speak to a lawyer before you post. What you write publicly can later be used in those proceedings.

Read more

Frequently asked questions

Can a clinic stop me from leaving a negative review?

Not simply because the review is negative. You may describe what happened to you and give your honest opinion. A clinic can only take action against content that is unlawful – for example false statements of fact, insults or someone else's private data.

Is it illegal in Türkiye to criticise a clinic online?

No. Fair criticism based on facts is generally protected. Insult is a criminal offence under Art. 125 of the Turkish Penal Code, and attacks on personality rights can lead to civil claims – but this concerns insulting language and untrue allegations, not honest negative experiences.

The clinic says it will file a criminal complaint against me. What does that mean?

Insult is generally prosecuted only if the person concerned files a complaint, within six months of learning of the act and who did it. A complaint does not mean a conviction: a prosecutor first decides whether there is a case at all. Take the threat seriously but calmly, and get advice from a lawyer admitted in Türkiye.

Can I be extradited from the UK over a review?

This is very unlikely. Extradition generally requires that the conduct is also a criminal offence in the UK, and criminal libel was abolished in England and Wales. A pending investigation could still matter if you travel to Türkiye again, so get advice before any return trip.

Can the clinic sue me in the UK?

In principle yes, if you live there. But a company trading for profit must show that your statement caused or is likely to cause it serious financial loss, and truth and honest opinion are full defences.

Should I accept money or a free revision to delete my review?

That is your decision, but read the terms carefully. Do not sign anything that waives your compensation claims or contains a broad confidentiality clause without legal advice. Google's policy also prohibits businesses from offering incentives to remove negative reviews.

Can I name the surgeon in my review?

Naming the doctor who treated you in a factual way is usually less of a problem than naming other staff. Stick to what that person did, avoid insults and do not publish private details such as phone numbers or social media profiles.

Can the clinic get my Google review deleted?

It can flag the review to Google, and Google removes content that breaks its policies – such as fake reviews, harassment or personal information. It can also seek a court order. An honest, factual review of your own experience is much harder to remove.

Sources

  1. Defamation Act 2013, section 1 (Serious harm) – legislation.gov.uk
  2. Defamation Act 2013, section 3 (Honest opinion) – legislation.gov.uk
  3. Defamation Act 2013 – table of contents (truth, public interest, website operators, jurisdiction)
  4. Google Maps user-generated content policy
  5. İFÖD EngelliWeb 2025: Civil courts and preliminary injunctions after the annulment of Article 9 of Law No. 5651
  6. Hukuki Haber: Hakaret suçlarında soruşturma yöntemleri – uzlaştırma, ön ödeme, doğrudan iddianame

Your comments

Do you have a question about this topic or want to share your experience? Write it here. Comments appear after a short review.

    Please do not post phone numbers, email addresses or other people’s health details. Comments are not medical or legal advice.

    You might also like

    Questions? WhatsApp